Many practitioners of historical fencing have little interest in the modern fencing disciplines, preferring the historical disciplines for a variety of reasons. However, every so often, the question arises: “is it worth learning modern fencing?”
My advice is that if you have the opportunity, it is worth spending some time learning foil fencing. There are some quite tangible benefits that come with this practice, and you cannot go far wrong by giving yourself this experience, even for a short while.
You do not need to learn foil fencing to be able to learn one of the historical disciplines. In fact trying to retrofit foil concepts into historical systems such as those for the longsword can actually hold back your development and throw up red herrings as you work with the older treatises. If you do take up foil fencing, treat it a what it is: its own self-contained discipline, that may have some similarities to other fencing systems, along with many key differences.
1) learning why the hands should move before the feet when attacking along a straight line
One of the pieces of advice you will doubtless hear again and again from instructors in any European fencing art is that the hands should move before the feet.
When you thrust with the foil, you do not step and try to make a thrust while on the move; you straighten your arm and then perform the lunge if (and only if) it is necessary to do so. There are various thrusting techniques that do not require a lunge, such as the thrust without a step, or even the thrust with a step backwards.
The reason is that if you move the body first, before creating threat with the weapon, then your opponent can react to your body, which is dangerous for you. If you move your sword first to create threat, before moving your body forward, then the likelihood is that your opponent will react to your sword instead of towards your body.
In foil fencing, you fight along a narrow strip of ground, called the “piste”. It is not wide enough for much stepping to the side, nor for circling, and so the fencing tends to be very linear in nature. Therefore, when you attack, you tend to do so along a straight line towards your opponent, and straightening the arm to move the foil before moving the body or feet is the best way to ensure your safety as you close the distance toward your opponent.
This is a good lesson for historical fencing disciplines when you attack along a straight line. However, some of the historical disciplines also involve passing footwork (instead of just lunges) and sidesteps, both of which can change the nature of the attack so that in some circumstances, it is best to move the body before the sword (for example in German longsword, when you make the second (crossed-arm) Zwerhaw after your first Zwerhaw has been parried).
Once you understand the rationale behind these mechanical rules, you can follow them or break them at your leisure, and you can make the right choice for the situation in which you find yourself.
2) it is a good fun, low-impact game with relevance
The modern fencing foil is a very light sword, weighing perhaps 350 to 400 grams, and is extremely flexible in the thrust. It is quite a different type of weapon from the longsword weighing 1400g and flexing only a few degrees in the thrust, or the basket-hilted broadsword weighing 1600 kilograms and not flexing at all in the thrust. It is even quite different from the military sabre weighing 850 grams without much flex in the thrust.
As a result, it is not very painful at all to spend an hour or two receiving constant thrusts to the torso or fencing mask when working with the fencing foil. While sometimes it may leave a little bruising, it is nothing compared to the kind of bruising that can result from sparring with historical weapons, and needs far less padding and protective gear (although Newton rated penetration-proof safety gear is strongly recommended for such light and flexible blades, in case of snapping).
The best way to develop skills, strength and stamina for a given kind of activity is by performing that activity or those closely related to it. Spending an hour jogging may improve your cardiovascular endurance in general, but it will not necessarily help you fence with the rapier for five hours at a time. Similarly, playing a 90 minute game of football will not make you a better wrestler or a better sword and buckler fencer.
Foil fencing requires many of the same skills and actions as are required for most historical fencing disciplines. Because of its general relevance to the kinds of motions required, it is a helpful game to play to develop your capacity for fencing, while still letting you do something a bit different for a while, with a lot less impact on the body from heavy hits.
3) you can learn the concept of priority
Whether or not you agree with how the rule of priority or right of way is handled and implemented in foil fencing, it is nonetheless a valuable concept to wrap your head around. If you can analyse in any given situation who has priority, i.e. who has initiated an attack and is presenting threat, and therefore who should be considering his own defence instead of making a suicidal counter-thrust, then you will have a much better ability to make sensible choices in sparring.
You do not need to try to shoehorn priority into your historical fencing, and indeed, sometimes that may have counter-productive results. For example, in foil fencing, once you parry an attack, it is your turn to make your own attack. However, in historical fencing, your opponent may make two, three, four, or even more attacks towards you in a long sequence. If you decide that after you make your first parry, it is now your turn to attack, without paying attention to the opponent’s body language and pressure, then you will still get hit (even if you manage to force a double hit, which is still bad martial arts).
It is useful to have an awareness of the theory of right of way and how to apply it in different situations. A working knowledge of priority is a healthy thing to possess, even if you choose not to apply the rule in your sparring!
4) it emphasises the value of fine detail manipulation of the sword without needing lots of body strength
Often, beginners feel that sword fighting should involve as much strength as possible, and they have difficulty relaxing and letting the sword do its thing without “muscling” techniques to completion.
As a thrusting weapon, without any cutting techniques, the foil is an ideal way to learn to use fine detail manipulation of the fingers without applying any real strength to the actions. Of course, you do need some strength to be able to make dynamic and explosive attacks, and to maintain a back-and-forth rally of thrust parry thrust parry thrust, but the raw strength required is significantly less than what you need to work with the longsword or the basket-hilted broadsword.
Learning to relax and to develop dexterity in the fingers and in the grip can be a valuable lesson for people who clench too tightly around the handle of their sword.
5) it gives you an appreciation for how other people solve the same problems
It is all too easy to fall into the trap of assuming that modern fencing is just sporty nonsense without promoting any sense of self-preservation, especially if your historical fencing instructor or club members have that kind of mindset.
However, you may discover that some modern fencing schools prioritise the motto of “touch without being touched”, and pace a greater emphasis on safe and secure fencing than you may have expected. Taking some foil fencing lessons and learning how other schools approach the same problems that we face in historical fencing (how to attack safely and securely, how to avoid being hit when attacked, how to deal with double hits, etc.). Such insights may broaden your knowledge and help you become a more mature and well-rounded martial artist.
"I thank the gods for being Greek" - Alexander the Great
‘Ακαδημία Ιστορικών Ευρωπαϊκών Πολεμικών Τεχνών’'Λεοντες': Εκπαίδευση μεσαιωνικής και αναγεννησιακής σπαθασκίας
Historican, Swordsman and all-round rascal
A Blog for Lovers of the 18th Century
Το περιεχόμενο των επώνυμων άρθρων ενδέχεται να μη συμπίπτει με τις απόψεις και θέσεις του διαχειριστού.(π.Δημ.Αθανασίου)
Minoan Linear A, Linear B, Knossos & Mycenae
A Resource for Historical European Martial Artists
FencingClassics from the Secret Archives of Fencing and Dueling
Just another WordPress.com weblog
ARGOLIKOS ARCHIVAL LIBRARY OF HISTORY AND CULTURE www.argolikivivliothiki.gr
Historical martial arts study group
Chronicles of the Past
Poking Each Other With Sticks Since 2006
Βιβλιοθήκη Κλασσικών & Φυσικών Επιστημών
A podcast telling the story of the Roman Empire from 476 AD to 1453
All Swords All The Time - Updates Tuesdays and Fridays
The French art of personal combat